Playing Politics

A values-based approach to internal influence for human rights and social performance leaders
1 July 2026

“Politics” and “power” are words that makes many human rights and social performance professionals uncomfortable. It conjures images of self-promotion, coalition-building, lobbying, and and institutional manoeuvring that often feel at odds with the values that drew us into this work in the first place. Yet, building a culture of corporate respect and value for human rights requires navigating politics and power. It requires mapping how decisions get made, who holds influence, and where resistance and support lives, so that one can intentionally and progressively move an organization toward sustainable outcomes that all stakeholders – companies, projects, communities and rights-holders – need. That is, by any honest definition, politics.

The question is how human rights and social performance leaders can engage in internal corporate politics in a way that is consistent with who they are, and what competencies they need to flourish to be successful.

The Values Foundation: Who We Are and Why That Matters


The State of Social and Human Rights Practitioners (SSHRP) survey’s dominant values analysis, using Schwartz’s theory of basic human values (1992), offers support in answering that question. Nearly seven in ten respondents (69%) hold Self-Transcendence as their dominant value orientation, defined by concern for others’ welfare and the transcendence of self-interest. A further 17% are primarily oriented toward Openness to Change, characterized by independent thought, intellectual curiosity, and readiness for new approaches. Together, these two orientations account for 85% of the values that define the professionals in our field.

Only 12% of respondents are primarily Conservation-oriented, motivated by security, conformity, and the preservation of existing structures, and a mere 2% are primarily Self-Enhancement-oriented, driven by power and personal achievement. This distribution is not incidental. It reflects a professional community that entered this field because it cares about people, and that sustains itself through meaning and purpose rather than status or control.

This values profile is both a strength and a problem to advancing human rights and social performance practice. It is a strength because Self-Transcendence and Openness to Change motivates genuine relationship-building, collaborative problem-solving, and the kind of adaptive thinking that complex institutional change requires. It is a problem because leadership positions in the organizations these practitioners work are often governed by Conservation and Self-Enhancement motivations: risk management, hierarchy, reputational protection, and competitive positioning.

This presents a paradox: human rights and social performance professionals motivated to build and sustain a Transcendent-and-Open organizational culture will lack part of the motivations and skills needed to pierce through dominant Conservation-and-Enhancement organizational cultures. Further, even if human rights and social performance professionals develop the necessary political and power motivations, wouldn’t they lose the original self-transcendent and open to change motivations? By learning about politics and power, professionals become part of the culture they wanted to change.

The challenge of values-consistent internal political strategy is precisely this: how to move a Conservation-and-Enhancement institution toward Transcendence-and-Openness outcomes, without adopting the institution’s values in the process.

“This presents a paradox: human rights and social performance professionals motivated to build and sustain a Transcendent-and-Open organizational culture will lack the motivation and skills needed to pierce through dominant Conservation-and-Enhancement organizational cultures.”

The Strategy: Reframing Organisational Influence


Effective internal political strategy for Self-Transcendence and Openness to Change practitioners requires a critical reframing. Organizational change led by such practitioners is less likely to follow the normative top-down, rule-based, and risk-avoidant drivers present in Conservation-and-Enhancement organizational cultures. Self-Transcendence and Openness to Change practitioners are required to move from doing in practice what they think is right, to become aware of their values and intentionally using those to gradually build institutional influence and lead organizational change.

1. Capitalising on “relationship infrastructure”. Self-Transcendence-oriented practitioners are naturally inclined toward genuine care for the people they work with, including colleagues, managers, and decision-makers who do not share their values. If used properly, this is not a weakness to be overcome, it is a political asset. Institutional influence is built on trust, and trust is built through predictable, dependable, and respectful engagement over time. The practitioner who is known to listen carefully, to represent others’ concerns accurately, and to follow through on commitments builds a form of relational capital that is both durable and transferable. When a critical decision arrives – a project approval, a policy revision, a budget allocation – that relational capital can be drawn upon in ways that purely transactional influence cannot replicate.

2. Moving from “moral obligations” to an “institutional risk”. Openness to Change practitioners are, by definition, comfortable with translating ideas across different frameworks and audiences. This cognitive resilience is essential to internal political effectiveness. Decision-makers who are primarily Conservation-oriented respond to arguments framed around risk, compliance, and institutional stability; and decision-makers who are primarily Self-Enhancement-oriented respond to arguments framed around competitive advantage, reputational positioning, and performance. These framings require social and human rights practitioners not to abandon their underlying values but to translate those values into a language that resonates with the audience – long term forecasting, social capital, sustainable decision-making. The goal of protecting communities, preventing harm, embedding human rights into decision-making remains unchanged, but the vocabulary shifts.

3. Using role experience as data about critical gaps. Up 50% of survey participants reported high levels of role ambiguity (uncertainty regarding role expectations, responsibilities, and performance criteria) and of role conflict (incompatible demands or expectations arising from multiple role senders or competing role requirements) This is uncomfortable, but it is also politically informative. The experience of role ambiguity and conflict is a powerful lens to see exactly where the institutional gaps are: where organizational incentives diverge from human rights obligations, where decision-making processes exclude the voices they should centre, where the gap between stated values and enacted values is widest. A practitioner who learns to read role experience as a diagnostic signal rather than simply as a source of personal stress will gain a map of where institutional change is most needed and most possible.

4. Building coalitions across the values spectrum. The 12% of social performance and human rights practitioners with Conservation-dominant values and the small Self-Enhancement group are not adversaries. They are colleagues who experience the same organizational pressures through a different values lens. Conservation-oriented colleagues are often the most effective allies for embedding human rights into governance structures, compliance frameworks, and risk management systems, because those are the institutional forms that resonate with their values. Self-Enhancement-oriented colleagues may be the most effective champions for human rights business cases that connect to market positioning or investor relations. Values-consistent internal political strategy does not require everyone to share the same motivation. It requires building coalitions in which different motivations converge on shared outcomes.

“The experience of role ambiguity and conflict is a powerful lens to see exactly where the institutional gaps are: where organizational incentives diverge from human rights obligations, where decision-making processes exclude the voices they should centre, where the gap between stated values and enacted values is widest.” (…). This matters most for your less experienced colleagues.”

The Constraint: When the Organisation Resists


The organizational culture data present a sobering reality: 25% of the sample works in Low Safety, Trust, and Balance environments. These are organizations where speaking up carries real risk, where dissent is not welcomed, and where the institutional culture actively suppresses the kind of reflexive and adaptive thinking that Transcendent and Open to Change practitioners bring. This is having real consequences: the data shows that professionals working in these environments report the lowest values in the sample on role experiences, well-being, and motivation.

In these environments, the political approach shifts. Direct advocacy may be less effective than strategic patience, identifying the moments when institutional conditions shift – a leadership change, a high-profile incident, a regulatory development – and being prepared to move quickly when the window opens. It may mean building external legitimacy, through professional networks, industry standards bodies, or academic partnerships, that can be brought to bear on internal debates. And it may mean being honest about the limits of what is achievable in a given institutional context, and preserving one’s own well-being and values integrity in the process.

The Opportunity


The SSHRP data ultimately describe a professional community that is primarily motivated by others’ welfare with deep reserves of relational capacity, intellectual flexibility, and moral seriousness. The bad news: these values are often at odds with the dominant Conservation-and-Enhancement organizational cultures where social and human rights professionals operate. The opportunity: these values support remarkably important practices for the kinds of internal political work that can lead to durable institutional change. The challenge to our professional community is to become: aware of the motivations guiding our behaviours; deliberate about the ways we can turn these motivations into a political and power language; and self-compassioned that playing the politics game is not a betrayal of values. The politics game, when done with the integrity that defines our professional community, is the one of most values-consistent impact a human rights and social performance leader can leave.

“The challenge to our professional community is to become aware of the motivations guiding your behaviours, deliberate about the ways we can turn those motivations into a political and power language, and self-compassioned that playing the politics game is not a betrayal of our own values.”

This article draws on findings from the Survey on the State of Social and Human Rights Practitioners (SSHRP) led by Dr. Ana Maria Esteves and Dr. Sérgio Moreira at Community Insights Group (CIG). The survey was conducted between December 2025 and February 2026 with 281 respondents across multiple sectors and regions. Full findings are available at sshrp.netlify.app.