1 November 2026
This last month, Frank gave his last lecture in his Social Impact Assessment course. There was nothing remarkable about the setting, the students, or the slidedeck to mark the extraordinary occasion. Next year he will retire, and there is a risk that University of Groningen will no longer offer Social Impact Assessment within its Master’s programme.
There is no neat and tidy emotion for a moment like this. Certainly, we feel pride. Frank Vanclay has spent a lifetime helping to establish and improve a field that asks deceptively simple questions: Who will live with the consequences of a project? What will change in their everyday lives? Who has a voice in shaping those changes? What rights, relationships, places, livelihoods and futures might be put at risk – or strengthened – by decisions taken far away?
Alongside pride there is discomfort: the sting of redundancy. It is one thing to choose to step back after a long career; it is another to watch a subject to which you have devoted so much care become institutionally dispensable. The feeling goes beyond the personal, it raises a wider question: what does it say about our priorities when the social consequences of development are treated as optional learning rather than essential knowledge?
Frank has never taught SIA as a procedural add-on to project approval. At its best, it is a practice of attention and accountability. It requires us to notice that people are not “stakeholders” in the abstract. They are neighbours, families, workers, farmers, elders, young people, Traditional Owners and Indigenous Peoples, each embedded in particular histories, attachments and unequal relations of power. It asks project proponents, regulators and financiers to understand consequences before they become harm, and to remain responsible long after the report is submitted.
This is why Frank’s work has always been about more than impact prediction. As Professor of Social Impact Assessment and Management at the University of Groningen, his work has connected SIA with human rights, community engagement, Free, Prior and Informed Consent, displacement and resettlement, benefit sharing and social licence to operate. The 2015 IAIA guidance on assessing and managing the social impacts of projects, of which he was principal author, helped set an international benchmark for good practice. It placed participation, social equity, Indigenous engagement and long-term social management at the centre, where they belong.
The thought of a final lecture therefore carries a paradox. A career can reach fulfilment precisely when the need for its central message remains unresolved. The more work Frank has done, the more obvious it has become that social issues cannot be solved through a single framework, a brilliant report or the goodwill of one institution. There will always be a temptation to treat consultation as delay, cooperation as naïveté and compromise as weakness. There will always be people and places whose experience is inconvenient to the story of progress. There will always be pressure to turn a complex human reality into a manageable risk register.
We have been thinking about different concepts to try make sense of this moment: ageing not only as a fact of the body but as a social judgement about usefulness; moral outrage as the recognition that a line has been crossed; the difference between hope and optimism.
We’re choosing hope plus outrage (while continuing to ignore the ageing for now). Optimism predicts a favourable outcome. Hope, more demanding and more durable, keeps faith with action when there is no guarantee of success. In a world where human rights conditions are deteriorating in too many places, where communities are displaced, silenced or asked to bear costs they did not choose, we should not lose our capacity for moral outrage. Outrage is not enough though, and it can become performative or exhausting. However, the absence of outrage can be worse: it can signal that we have started to accept the unacceptable. The challenge of the social performance practitioner is to turn moral unease into disciplined practice, into listening, evidence, participation, remedy, and the courage to change a decision when the evidence supports it.
Nor should we mistake the ending of a university course for the ending of SIA. Fields do not live only in curricula, they live in the questions people continue to ask, in the practitioners who refuse superficial engagement, and in communities that insist on being recognised as rights-holders rather than obstacles. They live in the shared professional and ethical standards that help us call poor practice by its name.
That is why Frank’s next project feels so timely. He is updating the IAIA 2015 SIA Guidance[1], with an invitation to renew it collectively. At IAIA27 in New Zealand[2], he will chair a participatory workshop, “SIA Guidance Update: Have Your Say!” Practitioners and stakeholders will discuss what the guidance did well, what it missed, and what needs to change for the decade ahead. The 2015 document has been translated into several languages and cited more than 800 times in English alone; there is no doubting its influence. However, good guidance must remain open to criticism, new realities and the knowledge of those whom it is meant to serve.
So, the last lecture was not a final word. It was a moment to acknowledge loss without surrendering meaning. Retirement will bring a change of rhythm, but not an end to attention, conviction or contribution. For those of us who care about community wellbeing, human dignity and just development, the task continues. We must keep asking who is heard, who benefits, who bears the risk, and what accountability requires.
A life’s work is not measured only by the institutions that continue to offer a course. It is measured by the people who carry its questions forward. On that measure, Frank’s work is still very much in motion.
Frank Vanclay is Professor of Social Impact Assessment at the University of Groningen in The Netherlands. He partners with CIG on various projects, bringing academic rigour and global perspective to the firm’s advisory work. He is also the life partner of CIG’s founder.